Wagner Hall offers thoughtfully appointed rooms in a quiet Brookhaven setting — where the rush of Long Island fades and rest actually happens.
200+
Guests per season
4.6
Guest rating
15
Minutes to town
Whether you're passing through Long Island or settling in for a longer stay, every room at Wagner Hall is furnished with the same care — clean lines, comfortable beds, and nothing you don't need.
A straightforward, comfortable room with a queen bed, work desk, and everything for a restful night.
Inquire now
More space for the whole group — two double beds, extra seating, and a generous work area.
Inquire now
Our largest room — a separate sitting area, premium bedding, and room to spread out for extended stays.
Inquire nowAvailability varies by season. We recommend calling ahead.
Call (631) 632-9449 to Check Availability
Wagner Hall sits on Circle Road in a part of Brookhaven that still feels like a refuge. The rooms are kept simple and clean, the grounds are quiet, and the pace here is whatever you need it to be.
Families, weekend visitors, people passing through Long Island — everyone who stays with us gets the same treatment: a comfortable room, a friendly greeting, and the freedom to make yourself at home.
From the beaches of the North Shore to the vineyards of the South Fork, Brookhaven puts you within reach of everything Long Island has to offer — and Wagner Hall is the place you come back to.
400 Circle Road sits in a well-connected part of Brookhaven — close enough to everything, quiet enough to sleep. Free parking is available on-site.
Address
400 Circle Rd
Brookhaven, NY 11790-3404
Phone
(631) 632-9449Check-in
Flexible — call to arrange
"We drove in late and just needed a good night's sleep. Wagner Hall gave us exactly that — and then some."
A recent guest
Wagner Hall is open year-round. Call us directly to check availability, ask questions, or make a reservation — we're always happy to help.
(631) 632-9449
Call any time — we'll answer
400 Circle Rd
Brookhaven, NY 11790-3404
We'll get back to you as soon as possible.
Message sent!
We'll reach out within 24 hours.
